American Dairy Goat Association

2004 ADGA Guidebook, Evaluation of defects

XVII. EVALUATION OF DEFECTS SUMMARY
(See XIII.E for additional information.)

BREED SPECIFICS

  • MODERATE DEFECTS
    • Alpine
      Mature does less than
          Minimum height (30 in./76 cm) Minimum weight (135 lbs./61.36 kg)
      Mature bucks less than
          Minimum height (32 in./81 cm) Minimum weight (170 lbs./77.27 kg)
      Does with Toggenburg color and markings
      Does all white color
    • LaMancha
      Mature does less than
          Minimum height (28 in./71 cm) Minimum weight (130 lbs./59.09 kg)
      Mature bucks less than
          Minimum height (30 in.761 cm) Minimum weight (160 lbs./72.72 kg)
    • Nigerian Dwarf
      Mature does less than
         Minimum height (17 in./47cm)
      Mature bucks less than
      Minimum height (17 in./47cm)
      (Refer to Appendix "Measuring the Nigerian Dwarf Breed)
    • Nubian
      Mature does less than
          Minimum height (30 in./76 cm) Minimum weight (135 lbs./61.36 kg)
      Mature bucks less than
          Minimum height (32 in./81 cm) Minimum weight (170 lbs./77.27 kg)
      Straight face
    • Oberhasli
      Mature does less than
          Minimum height (28 in./71 cm) Minimum weight (120 lbs./54.54 kg)
      Mature bucks less than
          Minimum height (30 in./76 cm) Minimum weight (150 lbs./68.18 kg)
    • Saanen
      Mature does less than
          Minimum height (30 in./76 cm) Minimum weight (135 lbs./61.36 kg)
      Mature bucks less than
          Minimum height (32 in./81 cm) Minimum weight (170 lbs./77.27 kg)
    • Sable
      Mature does less than
         Minimum height (30 in./76 cm)-Minimum weight (135 lbs./61.36 kg)
      Mature bucks less than
         Minimum height (32 in./81 cm)-Minimum weight (170 lbs./77.27 kg)
    • Toggenburg
      Mature does less than
          Minimum height (26 in./66 cm) Minimum weight (120 lbs./54.54 kg)
      Mature bucks less than
          Minimum height (28 in./71 cm) Minimum weight (150 lbs./68.18 kg)
      Few small white spots in hair of does

  • MODERATE TO SERIOUS DEFECTS
    Alpine
        Roman nose
    LaMancha
        Roman nose
    Nigerian Dwarf
       Roman nose
    Oberhasli
        Roman nose
    Saanen
        Roman nose
    Sable
       Roman nose
    Toggenburg
        Roman nose

  • SERIOUS DEFECTS
    Alpine
        Bucks with Toggenburg color and markings
    Bucks with all white color
    Oberhasli
        Small white spots in hair of does
    Saanen
        Dark cream color
    Several small dark spots in hair
    Toggenburg
        Black color in does
    White stomach on does
    Large white spot (1-1/2" [3.8 cm] or more in any direction) on does
    Few small white spots in hair of bucks
  • VERY SERIOUS DEFECTS
  • Nubian
        Dished face
    Barely drooping ears
    Oberhasli
        Small white spots in hair of bucks

  • GENERAL DEFECTS
  • (depending on degree on a comparative basis)

    SLIGHT TO SERIOUS

    • 1. Large scurs or stubs
    • 2. Undershot or overshot jaw
    • 3. Enlarged knees; nondisabling lameness
    • 4. Bowed over front knees, buck kneed
    • 5. Small boned for body size
    • 6. Loose, winged or heavy shoulders
    • 7. Narrow chest or pinched heart girth
    • 8. Short, shallow or narrow body
    • 9. Low backed or steep rumped
    • 10. Broken or wry tail
    • 11. Close in hocks
    • 12. Swollen hocks
    • 13. Swollen stifle joint
    • 14. Postiness
    • 15. Hind legs close together
    • 16. Sprung pasterns
    • 17. Turned out or crooked feet
    • 18. Udder of beefy texture or with pocket
    • 19. Front, rear or side udder attachment lacking
    • 20. Separation between halves of udder or presence of scar tissue
    • 21. Teats that are:
      • a. Set close together
      • b. Bulbous
      • c. Extremely large or small
      • d. Pointed sideways
      • e. Uneven in size
      • f. Having small streams or otherwise hard to milk
      • g. Not clearly separated from the udder
  • VERY SERIOUS DEFECTS
    • 1. Udder
      • a. Pendulous
      • b. Too distended to determine texture
      • c. Hard or swollen (except in does just fresh).
      • d. So uneven that one-half is less than half the size of the other
      • e. Udder lacking size
      • f. Double orifice in teat of doe
      • g. Extra teat or teats that have been cut off on does
      • h. Leaking orifice
      • i. Misplaced orifice
    • 2. Crooked face on does
    • 3. Very crooked or malformed feet
  • DISQUALIFICATIONS
    GENERAL
    • 1. Total blindness
    • 2. Serious emaciation
    • 3. Permanent lameness or difficulty in walking
    • 4. Blind or nonfunctioning half of udder
    • 5. Blind teat
    • 6. Double teat(s)
    • 7. Extra teat(s) that interfere with milking
    • 8. Active mastitis or any other cause of abnormal milk
    • 9. Evidence of hermaphroditism or other inability to reproduce
    • 10. Permanent physical defects, such as naval hernia
    • 11. Crooked face on bucks
    • 12. Extra teat(s) or teat(s) that have been cut off on bucks
    • 13. Double orifice in teats of bucks
    • 14. Buck with one testicle or with abnormal testicles

  • BREED SPECIFICS
    Alpine
        Pendulous ears
    LaMancha
        Anything other than gopher ears on bucks
    Ears other than true LaMancha type on does
    Nigerian Dwarf
       Pendulous ears
    Mature does over 22.5" (57cm), Mature bucks over 23.5" (60cm)
    (Refer to Appendix "Measuring the Nigerian Dwarf Breed)
    Nubian
        Upright ears
    Oberhasli
        Pendulous ears
    Black bucks
    Large white spot (1-1/2" [3.8 cm] or more in any direction)
    Any color other than chamoisee (or black in does)
    Saanen
        Large (1-1/2" [3.8 cm] or more in any direction) dark spot in hair
    Pendulous ears
    Sable
       Pendulous ears
    Solid white color
    Solid light cream color
    Toggenburg
        Tricolor or piebald
    Black bucks
    White stomachs on bucks
    Large white spot (1-1/2" [3.8 cm] or more in any direction) on bucks
    Pendulous ears

    Recorded Grades: A doe for which the recordation certificate specifies a breed-specific type, should be faulted only when the breed character defects would be regarded as a disqualification. The amount of this fault to be applied to a recorded grade should be as if it were a very serious defect

XVIII. ADGA SCORECARD

The goal of the Unified Scorecard is to aid in the selection of the type of dairy goat that can function efficiently over a long productive lifetime.

APPLICATIONS OF SCORECARD TO SENIOR DOES, JUNIOR DOES, AND BUCKS

Senior does and junior does are to be evaluated identically for general appearance and dairy character, giving due regard to the advantage of structural correctness maintained into full maturity. In considering the body capacity of junior does, as compared to senior does, slightly more emphasis should be placed on chest than barrel since extreme depth and width of barrel, particularly in the flank, can be a sign of overmaturity for the age. Although junior does have no points assigned for mammary system, very serious defects are discriminated against. No comment should be made on precocious udders, unless such an udder shows clinical signs of potential health abnormalities.

In evaluating the general appearance of bucks, heavier emphasis should be placed on front end assembly and legs, pasterns, and feet. Correctness and smoothness of movement assume a higher priority in males. Bucks can be expected to carry more weight when out of rut; they body capacity evaluation, particularly barrel, will be affected most by this phenomenon. Comment on the mammary system of a buck should be restricted to items listed as disqualifications in the evaluation of defects. Buck teats of normal structure yet with milk should not be discriminated against.

POINTS Senior
Doe
Junior
Doe
Buck
A. GENERAL APPEARANCE
An attractive framework with femininity (masculinity in bucks), strength, upstandingness, length, and smoothness of blending throughout that create an impressive style and graceful walk.
35 55 55
Stature - slightly taller at withers than at hips with long bone pattern throughout. 2 2 2
Head & Breed Characteristics - clean-cut and balanced in length, width, and depth; broad muzzle with full nostrils; well-sculpted, alert eyes; strong jaw with angular lean junction to throat; appropriate size, color, ears, and nose to meet breed standard. 5 10 8
Front End Assembly - prominent withers arched to point of shoulder with shoulder blade, point of shoulder, and point of elbow set tightly and smoothly against the chest wall both while at rest and in motion; deep and wide into chest floor with moderate strength of brisket. 5 8 10
Back - strong and straight with well-defined vertebrae throughout and slightly uphill to withers; level chine with full crops into a straight, wide loin; wide hips smoothly set and level with back; strong rump which is uniformly wide and nearly level from hips to pinbones and thurl to thurl; thurls set two-thirds of the distance from hips to pinbones; well defined and wide pinbones set slightly lower than the hips; tailhead slightly above and smoothly set between pinbones; tail symmetrical to body and free from coarseness; vulva normal in size and shape in females (normal sheath and testes in males). 8 12 10
Legs, Pasterns & Feet - bone flat and strong throughout leading to smooth, free motion; front legs with clean knees, straight, wide apart and squarely placed; rear legs wide apart and straight from the rear and well angulated in side profile through the stifle to cleanly molded hocks, nearly perpendicular from hock to B, yet flexible pastern of medium length; strong feet with tight toes, pointed directly forward; deep heels with sole nearly uniform in depth from toe to heel. 15 23 25
B. DAIRY CHARACTER
Angularity and general openness with strong yet refined and clean bone structure, showing freedom from coarseness and with evidence of milking ability giving due regard to stage of lactation (of breeding season in bucks).
Neck - long, lean, and blending smoothly into the shoulders; clean-cut throat and brisket.
Withers - prominent and wedge-shaped with the dorsal process arising slightly above the shoulder blades.
Ribs - flat, flinty, wide apart, and long; lower rear ribs should angle to flank.
Flank - deep, yet arched and free of excess tissue.
Thighs - in side profile, moderately incurving from pinbone to stifle; from the rear, clean and wide apart, highly arched and out-curving into the escutcheon to provide ample room for the udder and its attachment.
Skin - thin, loose, and pliable with soft, lustrous hair.
20 30 30
C. BODY CAPACITY
Relatively large in proportion in size, age, and period of lactation of animal (of breeding season for bucks), providing ample capacity, strength, and vigor.
10 15 15
Chest - deep and wide, yet clean-cut, with well sprung foreribs, full in crops and at point of elbow. 4 7 7
Barrel - strongly supported, long, deep, and wide; depth and spring of rib tending to increase into a deep yet refined flank 6 8 8
D. MAMMARY SYSTEM
Strongly attached, elastic, well-balanced with adequate capacity, quality, ease of milking, and indicating heavy milk production over a long period of usefulness.
35
Udder Support - strong medial suspensory ligament that clearly defines the udder halves, contributes to desirable shape and capacity, and holds the entire udder snugly to the body and well above the hocks. Fore, rear, and lateral attachments must be strong and smooth. 13
Fore Udder - wide and full to the side and extending moderately forward without excess non-lactating tissue and indicating capacity, desirable shape, and productivity. 5
Rear Udder - capacious, high, wide, and arched into the escutcheon; uniformity wide and deep to the floor; moderately curved in side profile without protruding beyond the vulva. 7
Balanced, Symmetry & Quality - in side profile, one-third of the capacity visible in front of the leg, one-third under the leg, and one-third behind the leg; well-rounded with soft, pliable, and elastic texture that is well collapsed after milking, free of scar tissue, with halves evenly balanced. 6
Teats - uniform size and of medium length and diameter in proportion to capacity of udder, cylindrical in shape, pointed nearly straight down or slightly forward, and situated two-thirds of the distance from the medial suspensory ligament on the floor of each udder-half to the side, indicating ease of milking. 4
TOTALS 100 100 100
Points Subtotal
E. SHOWMANSHIP
1. APPEARANCE OF ANIMAL 40
Condition and Thriftiness - showing normal growth neither too fat nor too thin. 10
Hair - clean and properly groomed.
Hoofs - trimmed and shaped to enable animal to walk and stand naturally.
Neatly disbudded if the animal is not naturally hornless.
10
Clipping - entire body if weather has permitted, showing allowance to get a neat coat of hair by show time; neatly trimmed tail and ears. 10
Cleanliness - as shown by a clean body as free from stains as possible, with special attention to legs, feet, tail area, nose, and ears. 10
2. APPEARANCE OF EXHIBITOR
Clothes and person neat and clean - white costume preferred. 10 10
3. SHOWING ANIMAL IN THE RING 50
Leading - enter, leading the animal at a normal walk around the ring in a clock-wise direction, walking on the left side, holding the collar with the right hand. Exhibitor should walk as normally and inconspicuously as possible.
Goat should lead readily and respond quickly.
Lead equipment should consist of a properly fitted collar or small link chain, which is inconspicuous, yet of sufficient strength to maintain proper control.
As the Judge studies the animal, the preferred method of leading is to walk on the side away from the Judge.
Lead slowly with the animal s head held high enough for impressive style, attractive carriage, and graceful walk.
10
Pose and show an animal so it is between the exhibitor and the Judge as much as possible. Avoid exaggerated positions, such as crossing behind the goat.
Stand or kneel where both Judge and animal may be observed
Pose animal with front feet squarely beneath and hind feet slightly spread. Where possible, face animal upgrade with her front feet on a slight incline. Neither crowd other exhibitors nor leave too much space when leading into a side-by-side position.
When Judge changes placing, lead animal forward out of line, down or up to the place directed then back through the line, finally making a U-turn to get into position. When a Judge changes placing in a head-to-tail sequence, lead animal out of line and up or down the line on the side next to the Judge. It is the responsibility of another handler to accommodate changes by moving up or down on the side opposite the Judge.
To step animal ahead - use slight pull on collar. If the animal steps badly out of place, return her to position by leading her forward and making a circle back through your position in the line.
When Judge is observing the animal, if she moves out of position, replace her as quickly and inconspicuously as possible.
Be natural. Overshowing, undue fussing, and maneuvering are objectionable.
15
Show animal to best advantage, recognizing the conformation faults of the animal you are leading and striving to help overcome them. Showmen may be questioned by the Judge on their knowledge of proper terminology for parts of a dairy goat, breed standards, evaluation of defects and ADGA Scorecards. 15
Poise, alertness, and courteous attitude are all desired in the show ring. Showmen should keep an eye on their animals and be aware of the position of the Judge at all times but should not stare at the Judge. Persons or things outside the ring should not distract the attention of the showmen. Respond rapidly to requests from judges or officials, and be courteous and sportsmanlike at all times, respecting the rights of other exhibitors. The best showmen will show their animals at all times not themselves and will continue exhibiting well until the entire class has been placed, the Judge has given his reasons, and he has dismissed the class. 10
TOTAL 100
Suggested Uniform: Long-sleeved white shirt, regulation white pants; 4-H or FFA necktie; 4-H or FFA cap (if applicable), with matching shoes and belt in either black, white, or brown.
F. HERDSMANSHIP
1. PREPARATION OF THE EXHIBIT
Adequate, clean bright bedding 10
Animals attractively space in pens 10
Decorations neat and attractive 10
Appropriate signs 5
Well-chosen color scheme - background, tack-boxes, etc. 5 40
2. APPEARANCE AND ATTITUDE OF EXHIBITORS
Knowledgeable, courteous, friendly, able to answer questions about exhibit or dairy goats. 15
Clothes and person neat and clean, appropriated dressed. 5 20
3. CARE OF THE EXHIBIT
Dairy goats clean, clipped (before show), feet trimmed. 20
Aisles kept neat and clean. 10
Attractive, organized feeders and feed equipment. Feed and equipment stored neatly when not in use (out of sight if possible), and kept clean. 10 40
TOTAL 100


American Dairy Goat Association ®
209 West Main Street  -  P O Box 865
Spindale,  NC  28160
Ph. (828) 286-3801  -  Fax (828) 287-0476
E-mail: info@adga.org

Material Copyright © 2002, 2003
American Dairy Goat Association ®